Today in class, we designed a discovery learning task for students to complete in science class. Last week, students worked in groups to complete an Egg Drop Challenge: to use teamwork to design a container that would protect a raw egg as it falls to the ground from a height of 5-8 feet. The students were given a list of materials, and provided with detailed graphic organizers that broke down each task into simple, concrete steps. Utilizing this scaffolding, students completed this activity, although, in all three homerooms, not a single egg survived the fall in tact.
Before moving on from our materials and objects unit, we decided to try a similar task, but to remove the scaffolding, and allow the students to self group and tackle a new challenge: to design a structure out of tin foil, straws, and tape that could hold as many pennies as possible while in a tub of water without sinking. With no structure or further directions, the students were all able to complete the task. It was wonderful watching them problem solve, use trial and error, and test out hypotheses independently. In addition to cognitive problem solving skills, they also needed to utilize 21st century skills. They needed to work collaboratively and innovatively, using their imaginations to discover a solution.
At the end of the class, the room was a mess and the students were excited and proud. And, all the groups in my homeroom were successful, with all structures able to float and hold pennies- one group's structure was able to hold 217 pennies before sinking.
Thursday, October 11, 2012
Saturday, October 6, 2012
Chapter 2: Cognitive Development
As I read chapter 2 of our text book, I found myself making many connections to the classroom.
First, the fact that infant learning initially occurs accidentally then intentionally through trial and error drew a connection to a colleague's 14 month old daughter, Jayden. The first time Jayden came to school, she was immediately attracted to the magnets on my filing cabinet. She took them off, one by one, then took great delight in putting them back on the filing cabinet, and watching them stick. She tried sticking the magnets on my desk, and discovered they didn't work quite the same, then went back to the filing cabinet. On each subsequent visit to the school, Jayden never fails to come to my filing cabinet and is able to remember where the magnets stick.
The opening vignette in this chapter is one in which a teacher gave her 3rd grade science class a problem to solve through trial and error. In the vignette, the students were unable to think logically about the problem they were posed because there were too many variables. Reading this made me think of a question on a science quiz that we recently gave our 5th graders:
A teacher carefully pops the balloon with a pin. The students pick up the pieces of the balloon and compare them. Which of the following properties of the pieces should be most similar?
A. color
B. shape
C. size
D. weight
In our weekly science team meeting, we analyzed data from the quiz, and found almost 80% of students answered this question incorrectly. Based on this percentage alone, we decided we needed to model this event (the balloon being popped) and allow the students to make actual observations and test their theories about which properties stayed the same before putting a question like this on a quiz. But, in reading this chapter, my ah-ha moment is to question whether or not this problem was developmentally appropriate for 5th grade students. Our students are currently in Piaget's concrete operational stage of development, where they are improving in their ability think logically, but unable to think abstractly. This makes me wonder whether our assessment was designed appropriately, and guarantees that we will keep the stages of cognitive development in mind when developing our next assessment.
Thinking about reversibility in the preoperational stage of development made me question why I have observed 5th graders struggle with this principle, particularly when doing inverse math equations (-/+, x/÷). For example, most of our 5th graders are able to tell you that if 3 + 5 = 8, then the opposite is: 8 - 5 = 3 by simply reversing the equation and using the inverse operation. But, when given the same equation 3 + 5 = 8 and this inverse: ___ - 3 = 5, our students struggle to fill in the missing digit of the equation. I wonder why having the same numbers but merely switching the order makes this problem more difficult to solve.
While reading about the concrete operational stage and the skill of transitivity, I immediately thought of the problem of the week we will introduce on Monday in math class:
First, the fact that infant learning initially occurs accidentally then intentionally through trial and error drew a connection to a colleague's 14 month old daughter, Jayden. The first time Jayden came to school, she was immediately attracted to the magnets on my filing cabinet. She took them off, one by one, then took great delight in putting them back on the filing cabinet, and watching them stick. She tried sticking the magnets on my desk, and discovered they didn't work quite the same, then went back to the filing cabinet. On each subsequent visit to the school, Jayden never fails to come to my filing cabinet and is able to remember where the magnets stick.
The opening vignette in this chapter is one in which a teacher gave her 3rd grade science class a problem to solve through trial and error. In the vignette, the students were unable to think logically about the problem they were posed because there were too many variables. Reading this made me think of a question on a science quiz that we recently gave our 5th graders:
A teacher carefully pops the balloon with a pin. The students pick up the pieces of the balloon and compare them. Which of the following properties of the pieces should be most similar?
A. color
B. shape
C. size
D. weight
In our weekly science team meeting, we analyzed data from the quiz, and found almost 80% of students answered this question incorrectly. Based on this percentage alone, we decided we needed to model this event (the balloon being popped) and allow the students to make actual observations and test their theories about which properties stayed the same before putting a question like this on a quiz. But, in reading this chapter, my ah-ha moment is to question whether or not this problem was developmentally appropriate for 5th grade students. Our students are currently in Piaget's concrete operational stage of development, where they are improving in their ability think logically, but unable to think abstractly. This makes me wonder whether our assessment was designed appropriately, and guarantees that we will keep the stages of cognitive development in mind when developing our next assessment.
Thinking about reversibility in the preoperational stage of development made me question why I have observed 5th graders struggle with this principle, particularly when doing inverse math equations (-/+, x/÷). For example, most of our 5th graders are able to tell you that if 3 + 5 = 8, then the opposite is: 8 - 5 = 3 by simply reversing the equation and using the inverse operation. But, when given the same equation 3 + 5 = 8 and this inverse: ___ - 3 = 5, our students struggle to fill in the missing digit of the equation. I wonder why having the same numbers but merely switching the order makes this problem more difficult to solve.
While reading about the concrete operational stage and the skill of transitivity, I immediately thought of the problem of the week we will introduce on Monday in math class:
PROBLEM OF THE WEEK: #4
Jocelyn, Henry, and Matty are folding origami paper
cranes. Henry folded 7 paper
cranes. Jocelyn folded 8 times as many
cranes than Henry. Matty folded 4 times
as many cranes and Jocelyn. How many
cranes were folded all together?
In order to be able to solve this problem, students will need to first figure out how many paper cranes Henry folded, then multiply this number by 8 to find out how many paper cranes Joclyn folded, then multiply that total by 4 to find the number Matty folded. Finally, students will need to add the three totals together to arrive at the final answer. 5th grade students should have the cognitive ability to solve this problem, and I will watch this week to see what students struggle with finding the relationships between the three people in this problem and the number of cranes each one folds.
Tuesday, October 2, 2012
Chapter 5: ABA vs. Self Motivation
Aside from the "Did you Know" video, my other big take-away/ah-ha moment/what I'm still grappling with is how to reconcile my background in special education, specifically the heavy behaviorist approach with what I'm learning now about Piagetian/Vgyotskyian theories of learning. If our ideal educational environment is one in which learns are self-motivated and internally driven to learn and complete tasks, how does behavior modification fit in? For 3 months, I worked as a paraprofessional in a sub-separate PDD ABA classroom, which is a straight behaviorist approach to education. Reinforces are strictly external (although a few of our students were able to communicate through limited speech, gestures, or use of a communication book, and could choose what they wanted their reinforcer to be) and the whole focus and emphasis is on modifying and learning concrete behaviors, which can then, ideally, be generalized into additional settings and locations.
In my job as a learning specialist, a large portion of my day is spent working with students with social/emotional impairments, and subsequently modifying behaviors as outlined in their IEPs. How, then, can I reconcile these very divergent points of view, and really meet the needs of my students? Now what!?
In my job as a learning specialist, a large portion of my day is spent working with students with social/emotional impairments, and subsequently modifying behaviors as outlined in their IEPs. How, then, can I reconcile these very divergent points of view, and really meet the needs of my students? Now what!?
Chapter 4: Diversity, the "Did You Know?" video, and Peace Corps
After seeing this video in class this weekend, I had to come back home and rewatch. I had this overwhelming realization while watching this that put things into perspective: in college, while I wasn't what you would call "tech savy" I was comfortable with technology and used it frequently in my daily life.
After college, I joined the Peace Corps and lived and taught for two years on the island of Lifuka in Ha'apai in the Kingdom of Tonga.
| the village I lived in, Koulo, on the island of Lifuka |
![]() |
| map of Tonga |
This island, approximately 2 miles wide and 7 miles long, did have it's own airport (in my backyard!) and a small branch of a regional college, but most homes, mine included, did not have electricity or running water, not to mention internet. In Pangai, the main town of this island group, there was intermittent internet access for those who could afford it, and I biked into town a couple of times each month to send emails and update my blog. In my village, I recognized the disadvantages growing up without internet had on my students, and I designed an introductory computer class that I was able to teach in the computer lab (donated by the Japanese and Australian governments) at the University of the South Pacific for a small weekly fee, to pay for the cost of electricity. I wanted my students to, at the very least, have some experience with computers and technology, and for many of them, this was their first time using a computer.
| at the Ha'apai branch of the University of the South Pacific for our computer classes |
| class 6 students on the computer for the first time! |
While I understood the detriment of growing up without technology for my students, I think I failed to fully comprehend the impact that such limited technology used would have on my life, once I returned to America. When I got back in the fall of 2010, I underwent culture shock in almost every activity I did in my daily life, from extreme (going to a supermarket) to mundane (the weather!). However, the most lasting impact, I am still realizing, has been regarding my ease and comfort using technology. When I left the country in 2008, there was no twitter, and facebook still required a .edu email account. When I returned, I was completely overwhelmed by the presence of technology in the lives of my friends and family, and, I still don't feel as though I've fully caught up. I still haven't been on or visited twitter, and I find checking my personal, work, and school email all in one day exhausting and overwhelming. My discomfort in using technology, specifically social media, in my daily life is something I am slowly working to understand and remedy. However, I am left to wonder what the impact of my experiences without technology, and my subsequent unease have in terms of my job teaching 5th grade, and what the broader implications are for how I both learn and teach in the 21st century. Watching this video brought these questions explicitly to the forefront, and my ah-ha moment came in the full realization of this fact.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








